Observer
Search
Visit cayCompass.com
Today's Date: 09 February 2012
CayCompass Community
Find us on Facebook
Find a:
The madness of magic
Commentary
By: Guy P. Harrison | guyfeedback@gmail.com
15 August 2010

Do you ever feel like turning your back on humanity, just giving up on the entire warped species you were born into?

I confess to occasionally wrestling with such negative impulses. After a recent viewing of a documentary about the treatment of “child witches” in Africa, for example, I found it difficult to accept my membership in such a loony and pathetic club as ours.

The film, “Saving Africa’s Child Witches”, pulls no punches in showing how many babies and children have their lives shattered by the evil ignorance of the adults around them.

If you are curious about just how low human stupidity and cruelty can fall to, this is a film for you. Ostracized, imprisoned, tortured and even murdered, these “child witches” suffer the brunt of irrational belief in magic and witches.

In most cases there is no reason at all for one child to be accused over another. Sometimes it is only because the child is “different” in some minor way.  Some desperate parents pay as much as a year’s salary to a preacher who promises to be able to “cure” children of witchcraft’s grip. Many parents simply disown their kids and turn them out into the streets.

Africa’s problem with belief in magic and witches is widespread. A recent article in The Atlantic magazine reports that more than 40 per cent of the court cases in Central Africa involve witchcraft prosecutions—as if that region doesn’t have enough reality based problems. But this is not Africa’s burden alone. The general lack of skepticism in the face of absurd claims allows irrational belief in magic and witches to run rampant around the world.

Mobs beat and kill “witches” in rural India on a regular basis. Meanwhile, in the United States shameless preachers drain millions of dollars from gullible people year after year in the name of fighting witchcraft. US politician Sara Palin — widely viewed as a serious contender for the presidency in 2012 — apparently believes in magic and witches. If you don’t believe it, watch the YouTube video of an African preacher performing a ritual on Palin meant to protect her from “the spirit of witchcraft”. Think about it: a witch-believer who may end up with her own nuclear arsenal. Scary stuff.

Magic belief is present in the Cayman Islands too. More than a few Caymanians have warned me about the dangers of obeah (Caribbean-style magic). Every year or so one hears ridiculous concerns here about the danger of Harry Potter books or the threat of some children’s movie seducing kids into witchcraft. But here is all that one needs to know about that: If you don’t want your child to get involved in magic, then simply explain to them that magic is not real and no modern person should be silly enough to believe in it.

Several years ago I saw a dead frog with a padlock someone had clipped through its mouth before leaving it on the steps of the George Town Courthouse. An old-timer explained to me that it was an obeah-inspired attempt to silence a witness in court.  It seems someone was undeterred by Cayman’s laws against the use of magic.

Yes, in case you didn’t know, past Caymanian legislators actually took the time to legally prohibit something that does not exist. We still don’t have that conservation law on the books but magical potions involving bat wings and eye-of-newt are well covered by our legal system. I wonder how many years one can get in Northward Prison if caught flying on a broom. But Cayman’s anti-magic laws are not just laughable; they likely are counterproductive as well. By criminalizing magic, Cayman’s government encourages belief in the nonsense by suggesting that there is something to it. Sure, someone may threaten another person or even poison them in the context of magic but so what? We already have laws against threatening and poisoning people. Should we also have immigration laws against ghosts and gargoyles who may have entered the country illegally? Should we have special legislation to allow fishing for the Loch Ness Monster within Cayman’s Marine Parks? And what about a zero-tolerance law to finally take a stand against fairy abuse?

It is unfortunate that the memo about the Dark Ages having ended a thousand years ago failed to reach so many people. For otherwise normal folks to even take seriously the concept of magic and “child witches” is tragic enough, but for innocent children to suffer neglect and abuse as a result of such beliefs is beyond comprehension and unforgivable. But no one should be surprised. Tragic consequences often follow close behind irrational beliefs. Foolish and unfounded claims are dangerous because there is always the likelihood that somebody somewhere will take them seriously and act accordingly. This is why scepticism and critical thinking are vital to civilization.

Magic is an unfounded belief you don’t need rattling around in your head taking up valuable space. And you certainly do not want to be philosophically aligned with child-witch killers, do you? After several thousand years of wild claims and crazy stories, no one has ever proved that magic is real. No one has even managed to produce any compelling evidence. Can science explain everything? Of course not. However, unanswered questions should never be used as excuses to surrender one’s mind and jump on board with Ouija boards, Harry Potter boycotts and witch hunts.

 Guy is the author of “Race and Reality” and “50 Reasons People Give for Believing in a God”. Contact him at guyfeedback@gmail.com

 
Share your Comment
We welcome your comments on our stories. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited.
IMPORTANT IDENTITY INFORMATION: You will be able to create a ‘nickname’ which will allow you to remain anonymous, however, whilst we collect login information from you, this information will be kept confidential and only used to contact you directly, if required. We require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification.
Please login to comment on our stories.    Log In | Register
 
 
Copyright © 2012 Cayman Free Press Ltd. All Rights Reserved.